Editing music-based video
Over the course of my professional editing career, I’ve enjoyed editing a wide range of music-based projects. These have included editing music-based videos for the BBC, complex insert roll music based editing for Top Of The Pops and many short films for broadcast on network television. Editing films and video images to and with music is a passion of mine.
Music video production
In an ideal scenario, your video editor will be involved before any filming starts. This would allow for the editor’s technical knowledge and creative perspective to be considered at the production stage and certainly before the shoot. An editor might suggest different ways of filming some elements or request additional shots to be filmed. Their input could help save money, result in a quicker editing process and prevent any further filming later in the music videos production.
If the music track is being supplied as a finished track then all a video editor has to edit together are the supplied visual elements along with any elements the editor creates. In a way that is quite different to editing a documentary or story led film where you would start to edit together the story first with sound. The editor of a music video may still need to tell a story or explain a concept but would now do this using a range of visual imagery alone.
Editing a music video
To edit a music video some of the main elements you may need to consider are:
What are the best vocal sync performances?
Can you include all the best visual shots?
What is the cut-rate – possibly linked to the track BPM (beats per minute)?
Will you be editing in any other performances?
Is there a relevant storyline?
What different cameras and camera angles are there to consider?
Has a visual style been agreed?
What visual effects will suit the video?
Are any complex visual compositions required?
Will the music video contain any animations?
Will the music video contain any additional graphical elements?
Are there any colour grading style requirements?
What is the agreed timetable for the edit?
What is the agreed timetable for the artistic, production and management sign-off?
What is the final technical file delivery specification listing the raster size and any compression requirements?
Starting the music video edit
Of course, there are many ways to approach every edit. I have written this article as if I was approaching a music video that contains a vocal performance and is filmed with a multi-camera recording.
If I was starting an edit after filming the first thing I would do would be to talk to the creative lead on the project and gain an understanding of what they were looking for. The creative lead may be a producer, the musicians themselves, the artist’s management or even an agency representing the artists.
Once you have the media, have look through the material and get a sense of what has been filmed.
If the music track contains vocals that are being sung the first thing I would do is sync up the video for the best vocal performances. You can do this manually by matching up the guide track to the master track or you can use software applications to help. It might be the case that you have many different takes with more that one camera filming.
Editing multi-camera shoots
If it’s a multi-camera shoot I would first group clip (I’m editing using Avid) every recording and then edit in the performances with the group clip. If you associate each multi-camera performance with a group clip before you start editing you can then easily switch between camera angles in the timeline.
Perhaps you are editing a multi-camera performance with many takes. Ideally, you will have received a script that lists the best takes to edit in. After grouping each set of camera takes you can then edit in the group requested. If you have not received any editing notes or guidance my advice would be to edit in the best group takes onto different vision layers. If you start the edit with all the best performance takes synced into position on different video layers then you have a master timeline to refer back to. Of course, this all depends on the amount of time allocated to the editing process.
Naming incremental editing timelines
With edit 1 being your master timeline create a duplicate of this edit and call it edit 2. You can then repeat this process as you progress your edits incrementing the edit timeline numbers at different stages in the editing process. This means that you always have a previous copy of the last edited timeline to refer back to.
By having a master edit with all the best performances in sync can be really helpful should your producer or creative’s want to check to see if there is a better performance available.
Over time you will gain a perspective on what shots and performances work best and feel strong for the edit.
After syncing up the best performances and selecting the best camera angles the next thing to consider would be any specific shots that are needed to tell the story so to speak (if applicable).
Any other required elements, performances or shots that you have seen that work well can be edited in at this stage.
Painting the edit
The editing in of non-synchronous shots or general view type shots is referred to as ‘painting’. This would be a good time to start ‘painting’ in any visual gaps in the music video timeline with shots that work well. By the end of this stage, you would have a timeline with visual images for the whole of the music track.
By now you should be starting to edit to the cutting rate that has been agreed or that you consider suitable for the music track in the video. Perhaps you have started to add some visual effects to the shot footage or have started to experiment with different visual looks or options that will determine the style of the final video.
At this point, the music video will be starting to get edited into some kind of shape. Depending on the timeframe that you have to deliver the edit and the agreement that you have it could be time to show the edit to your lead creative or producer. This could give them the opportunity to see how the music video edit is shaping up and allow for creative input if required.
By working with the producer or musicians involved in the project you can deliver a final music video that meets the creative vision and brief for the project.
From simple slow straight cut based editing to fast-paced composited multi-layered effects editing the video editor plays an essential role in enhancing and delivering the creative vision for every music video available today. If I can help with any questions you may have or editing your music based projects please do get in touch.